Thursday, November 17, 2011

The age-old question...

does this make me look fat?

And do NOT tell me "It's fine" or I'll smack you.

Back story:  I made this sweater, Hathersage, last February.  Loved the yarn, loved the look of the pattern but hated the finished product on me.  I felt like a cozy, wool-wrapped blimp, and so never wore it.  Oh, I tried it on periodically, hopefully,  but never felt the love.  So, I had plans to frog it and use the yarn for  the Campus Jacket.

I finally brought it downstairs to rip out yesterday, but on a whim threw it on and went grocery shopping, giving it one last chance to impress me, a last-minute stay of execution.  I still felt fat, and the boys thought it looked too boxy, but it was suggested that if I moved the buttons again (they're not even sewn on, they're attached with safety pins because I just couldn't get it right) it might actually be okay.
I am still giving serious thought to the Campus Jacket as I love it but will certainly NOT be buying yarn for it, but I guess needed to bounce this out there, give myself a visual to think about and maybe seek opinions.  I am on a big sweater-ripping binge right now, currently frogging my February Lady sweater - it's like free yarn! - so I have no qualms about that.

Hmmm...

off topic, but still about the photo - look to the right mid-frame... that back room... a fluffy lump.  Can't see it?
How about now?

That's Maggie, on "her" couch - she adopted it when she was a puppy, and now, 10 years later, it's the saddest piece of furniture I've ever seen.  And yet, she loves it as it is - I've tried blankets and slipcovers just so I can stand it, but they are promptly ripped off and have even been shredded on occasion... the boys and I have agreed that we have to keep it for as long as she's here.   Lucky dog.

3 comments:

Wanderingcatstudio said...

I think the problem with the sweater is the asymmetrical front. I have ... ahem... "good child-bearing hips" and I find anything that buttons like a kimono is not flattering on my figure - it's like drawing a line from my shoulder right down to my hip. I have a heck of a time looking nice in bathrobes.
I'd go with something that buttons straight down the middle (and with a little waist shaping)
The yarn does look nice and cozy!

Sandra said...

It looks cozy, but it's definitely more "jacket" looking rather than "sweater" looking.
If you're not comfortable, then rip it. I dod that a lot (I've recently ripped a couple of sweaters and gained some really nice wool from them!)

deirdre said...

Ahh, yes, the 'child-bearing hips'...

thanks both so much for your input - you have helped me decide, and we are off to the frog pond...